Abstract
Background The Empathizing-Systemizing theory proposes that individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder are systemizers and prefer Intense music characterized as loud , distorted, electric and percussive musical attributes and aggressive emotional attributes, typical of genres such as heavy metal, hard rock. However, there have been no studies that have tested this theory in a cross cultural setting. Aim The aim of this cross-cultural study is to gather music preferences by Indians and Non-Indians (US and Europe) and verify Baron-Cohen’s hypothesis. Method The Indian population of 20 participants (n=20; male, aged - 18-24 years), were contacted directly while for the Non-Indian population of 30 participants (n=25; US, n=5; Europe, male, aged 18-24) , we used social media platform Reddit (r/asperges and r/autism sub-reddit groups). Semi structured interviews were conducted to gather their demographic information, music they liked and disliked and how listening to music helps them in everyday life. Subsequently a mix of 10 songs each were curated comprising 5 songs they liked and out of the remaining 5 songs , 3 are of the genre they liked and 2 of the genre they disliked, taken from other individual’s playlist in a controlled setting. While playing each song, their likert responses (Like, Neutral, Dislike) were recorded per stimulus. Music Preferences were assessed based on the MUSIC model framework. Results Out of 20 participants, 18 preferred a mix of relaxing, non-aggressive, slow, quiet and instrumental musical attributes categorized as mix of Mellow and Sophisticated factor which helped in improved sleep and social skills and disliked music with loud and rebellious musical attributes categorized as Intense factor which shows that music serves for emotion regulation towards positive emotions in Indian population. In comparison , out of the 30 participants 22 preferred music categorized as Intense factor which brought in a calming factor when stressed and disliked music categorized as a mix of Mellow and Sophisticated factors which shows that music serves to discharge negative emotions in the Non-Indian group. Implications These results provide support to the Empathizing–Systemizing Theory for Non-Indian population but not for Indian population. It also suggests that cultural differences affect emotional arousal. These findings are helpful to build a recommendation system based on an individual’s preferences that can help in arousal regulation, sensory modulation difficulties commonly found among individuals with ASD.